Home Business NewsFinance News Justin Urquhart Stewart: Forecasting currencies is like trying to catch a falling knife

Justin Urquhart Stewart: Forecasting currencies is like trying to catch a falling knife

12th Jan 15 6:39 am

The founder of Seven Investment Management

For many investors, managing currencies is the imponderable factor. They can go up and down, often erratically move against each other and there is little apparently that you can do about it! Or if you do try and do something about it, the actions can be quite expensive and not always succeed.

The phrase is often used (and often by me as a limp excuse) about trying to forecast currency movements as being more like trying to catch a falling knife. For many private investors trying to have your own currency hedging policy can be pretty pricey and certainly time consuming. Even for most advisers, the opportunity of running a currency hedging and a management programme is often beyond the capability of their systems and platform – as well as their own personal experience.

For some more adventurous investors (or are they just foolhardy?) there is always the ‘opportunity’ of using one of the retail foreign exchange online trading platforms.

Now for professional investors with experience, these have been an astonishing technological development.

However, I have been concerned over the promotion for some of these platforms, often from overseas, which always sound very butch and enticing for the individual to be able to ‘trade like the professional’.

Beware the clever copywriting

The adverts on some of the more specialist television channels portray both the slick and the beautiful against a background of exciting trading markets ready for you to participate in, with the tempting goal of garnering trading profits alongside the investment banks with all their teams and capital.

Beaches, babes and boundless riches are yours for the taking if you just sign up to the foreign exchange trading platform of your dreams – or maybe they turn out to be nightmares. Some will even offer ‘educational programmes’ to learn and hone their ‘trading skills’, but much of this is illusory and the results rarely seem to support the claims.

To add some paraffin to this already heated conflagration, punters are often encouraged to increase their ‘get rich quick’ odds and leverage or borrow to further ramp up their bets in the hope of magnifying their gains – without necessarily appreciating the downside of this when the markets reverse and the punter is wiped out.

Ah but fear not, they have an answer to protect you – the stop loss orders which you are often encouraged to take – for potentially another small fee. The effect of the stop loss though is to ensure that successful trades are capped, and although the downside may have been protected, the benefit of any such leverage would have been lost.

Actually for many such platforms they don’t care, as they just want the trading and their real benefit comes from the spread in the dealing trade, which is why they often promote themselves as commission-free – which is certainly not the same as free!

A frightening reality

The reality, though, is frightening for many of these platforms, be they for FX or any other form of spread-betting. The figures show that most of their clients lose money, and thus they depend upon a constant replenishment of new clients to replace the burn-outs. Figures from France indicate that nearly 90% of clients actually end up losing money with the average loss being at around €11,000. Additionally the figures seem to show that there was no correlation between trading experience and making money, and that those who carried on trading just saw their losses pile up higher!

Frankly these online gambling sites are no more than that but with some slick advertising built around them to add an air of credibility and apparent strength.

This industry encourages the worst aspects of ‘investing’ as of course it is not investing but punting in an unregulated and dangerous world, which contributes little to the reputation of the investment world, by enticing inexperienced customers into dangerous areas, and of course manages to avoid taxation which proper investors have to suffer when buying shares for real investing.

But currency management is essential

However, for running investment portfolios correctly, in my view, currency management is essential. After all, for most investors a broadly diversified portfolio across the globe and across a broad range of asset classes will have a significant currency exposure.

By way of example, we had hedged around a third of our US Dollar exposure in November. Although there was still a decent case in favour of the Dollar, we were concerned that the Dollar had moved too far, too fast and had become a very widely-held position, with a lot of good news already in the price. We were wary that the Dollar could experience a correction.

More recent data confirms that the US economy is performing well. GDP data in Q4 was stronger than expected, confidence surveys are running at high levels and the labour market is continuing to recover.

Low oil prices will give a further boost to the economy and will improve the US balance of payments too. The Federal Reserve has changed its language around how long we should expect to wait for interest rate hikes.

So the Dollar may perform well if the US economy continues to outperform, and interest rates start to rise. However, we were also attracted to the Dollar as a possible beneficiary, if weaknesses in Europe (for example around the upcoming Greek election) led to further bouts of market volatility.

The Dollar doesn’t always strengthen when risky assets come under pressure, but it has the potential to do so, as investors flock into traditional safe havens.

Thus on Christmas Eve, we removed our US Dollar hedges (with the Dollar at around 1.5540 vs. Sterling) – so will benefit if the US$ strengthens: for most portfolios, this means we now have around 15-16% exposure to US$, in addition to holdings of Asian currencies with a strong link to the Dollar.

It’s very early days, but with Sterling-Dollar closer to 1.50 as I write, the trade has been a good one so far. The cost is small, especially when spread across the portfolios, but the opportunity for risk control as well as taking advantage of opportunities is very valuable. That then is an investment structure, not a currency punt.

This article represents a personal and lighthearted view from 7IM, and is based on current financial news and events around the world. Its content should not be used for investment purposesand you should contact an independent financial adviser before making any investment or financial decision.

Justin Urquhart Stewart is the founder of Seven Investment Management and a regular media commentator. Originally trained as a lawyer, he has observed the retail market industry for 30 years whilst in corporate banking and stockbroking.



London finance news, trends & insights

Mervyn King

Was the Bank of England oblivious to impending meltdown in 2007?


Fat Cat banker 300

FTSE 100 CEOs earn more in 2 days than most Brits do in a year

Leave a Comment


Sign up to our daily news alerts

[ms-form id=1]