Home Business News Government’s growth strategy at risk from new UK audit regulations

Government’s growth strategy at risk from new UK audit regulations

by LLB Finance Reporter
28th Sep 22 12:07 pm

A new discussion paper, Accounts and Accountability, published today by the Institute of Economic Affairs, highlights the risks presented by the government’s planned regulatory interventions in the financial reporting and auditing market.

The proposals are the result of three government-led inquiries into the sector, following the failures of BHS in 2016 and Carillion in 2018. The inquiry findings and proposals were collected in the government’s 2021 consultation document Restoring Trust in Audit and Corporate Governance. In May 2022, the government published its response to the consultation.

Among other things, the government proposes to dictate the content of financial reports, require the ‘Big Four’ audit companies to undergo internal re-organisations, oblige FTSE 350 companies to appoint two audit companies, and create a regulatory agency with greater powers. As the author highlights, each proposal is harmful.

Government-mandated information production is sure to be inefficient. Companies already have a commercial interest in supplying investors with any information those investors value more than it costs to produce.

The proposal to force Big Four audit companies to further separate their audit and non-audit operations is based on a misunderstanding of the incentives created by integration and ignores the market disciplines faced by auditors.

The proposal to reduce audit market concentration by forcing FTSE 350 firms to appoint at least one non-Big Four auditor fails to appreciate the genuine benefits of scale in auditors. It also constitutes an outrageous intervention in the decision-making of private enterprises and a state mandated subsidy for second-tier auditing firms.

The paper concludes that an enlarged financial reporting regulator with stronger powers will increase legal uncertainty for businesses operating in the UK. Contrary to their intended effect, the government’s proposed regulations will make the UK a less attractive place in which to invest.

Commenting on the report, author and IEA fellow Dr Jamie Whyte, said, “If the government wants to make the UK a more attractive destination for investment, it should not subject commercial enterprises to the arbitrary diktats of bureaucrats and politicians.

“The new administration has said it wants to cut unnecessary red tape on businesses. Reversing plans to increase business regulation is an obvious place to start.”

Leave a Comment

You may also like


Sign up to our daily news alerts

[ms-form id=1]